Monday, December 11, 2006

The American MT

The American MT is usually a working mother who manages her household, children, and husband while working full time from her home office. She works piecemeal for pennies per line. She is expected to produce at least 1200 lines in an 8 hour day. She is expected to be well versed in medical terminology, human anatomy and physiology, pharmacology, and the English rules of grammar, punctuation, and spelling. The American MT is usually an independent contractor receiving no healthcare benefits. The American MT does all of this for an average of 8 cents per line.

The American MT is now losing her job to overseas outsourcing. Many medical transcription services are now sending more than half of their U.S. based transcription accounts to India and Pakistan where it is typed by English-as-a-second-language "medical transcriptionists" who work for 4 cents per line or less. The work of these overseas transcriptionist usually require extensive editing before actually becoming part of the American patient's medical record. Who edits and corrects these reports? The American MT who is now expected to edit and correct these reports for 4 cents per line or less.

Medical transcription has steadily declined since I began as an MT almost 20 years ago. Of course, in those days working at home was merely a pipe dream realized only by transcriptionists willing to pick up standard size cassette tapes from doctors offices, transcribe and print reports at home, and hand deliver them back to the office. Therefore, the majority of MTs worked in offices making $12 an hour which at that time was a very good wage. We were considered medical professionals with a very distinct and specialized skill.

With the fast pace of the medical field came an emphasis on production and faster turnaround times, but MTs were compensated for their efforts. Still making our hourly wage, we were offered incentive bonuses that equaled 4 to 5 cents per line for production of over 1000 lines a day. We were making very good money, were treated like professionals, and felt like we were making a contribution to the care of the patient.

Eventually, the emphasis on production turned into an obsession and with the internet came the realization that medical reports could be typed and sent electronically and turnaround times became shorter. With the digital boom, came the realization that everything could be done electronically through our personal computers and MTs could work at home without the hassle of picking up tapes and delivering work. We virtually never had to leave our homes.

Medical transcriptionists gradually lost their face. We became words on a screen, an email address, and finally machines much like the computers we type on. When we ceased to be "real" people, so ceased the hourly wage. We became machines paid only for what we put out. And just like with all technology, we became outdated, nearly obsolete. We've been forced to adapt, accept a humilatingly low per line rate. We've been forced to compete for our jobs with workers who live in poverty and are willing to take almost anything and call it a wage. We are being told that all that knowledge we've worked so hard to build up and keep up has been for nothing. It is worth nothing. No, it is worth about 8 cents per line.

Well, I think it is time to show our faces again. For too long medical transcriptiont has been considered the red-headed stepchild of the Health Information Management department, too easy to forget, and even easier to get rid by sending the work out. By sending the transcription work out, hospitals got rid of the MTs, and freed up more office space for more "important jobs." For too long the medical transcription service owners have treated us like slaves, cracking the whip over us and saying "faster, faster!" We need to make our presence felt by refusing to accept the peanuts they throw at us. We need to boycott the services who send transcription overseas. We need to let our government know that a global economy benefits only the greedy and does nothing for the little guy or girl.

I started this blog to post my thoughts, my rants, and my suggestions for my profession, medical transcription. I plan to rock the boat of medical transcription and in the next few weeks I will be posting a list of medical transcription services that outsource overseas. I encourage everyone who reads my blog to post comments, suggestions, or your rants. We are in this together. If you don't agree with me, let me know. If you do agree with me, let me know.

The American medical transcription industry has become a sweat shop in a third-world country, only the sweat shop is right here in American, in our own homes.

If you'd like to contribute to my boycott list of MTSO's, email me or post a comment!

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

You said it all. When the hospitals closed their departments, that was a clue as to how much we were appreciated. As an MTSO employee, it was a sweat shop with no talking, no stopping. "Those typewriters mean money." I became my own MTSO in time for computers and spent the time looking up anything at all that sounded unfamiliar,which I was not allowed to do working for someone else. I spent time calling the docs, even delivering stats myself before the fax machine. Since the third world countries came around at .04 cpl not only quality went out the door, but confidentiality and credibility. I am almost ashamed to admit what I do. I have seen some of the trash coming out of these other countries. I correct my own records which contain mistakes which could be devastating. The bottom line is the .04 cpl. I was told as an independent contractor,"We can get it for far less." Well, go ahead. See you in court when the malpractice trial comes up. Do they care who typed the report? Yes, the lawyers sure do. I also worked in legal transcription and the lawyers went right down to the typist's initials and the doctor had to explain that he used a service, what time he called, etc. Only then will they wake up and smell the coffee. In the meantime, I am disgusted with my so-called profession. I was recently offered a job as an editor from someone using a service in India. They wanted me to "clean up the dictation." I said a resounding, "No." I would rather wash floors than support these people.I also don't like that my next-door neighbor may be getting my reports. They don't care who they hire. I get E-mails from that country - "Take on all the work you can, send it to us, and wake up in the morning and your work will be back." I don't think so - not the kind of work I am used to. All I can say, is read it, read it, it's awful. I guess the docs don't care. If they do care, it doesn't matter - the purchasing department goes for the price!

Anonymous said...

Well said. And while we're at it, can we address the problem of mumbling, yawning, sneezing, eating, etcetera, etcetera people who dictate a bunch of garbage that we conscientious MTs spend way too much time trying to decipher. I think everyone would agree that if there was a standard for the people who do the dictating so that they would be required to enunciate clearly then we MTs wound't have to spend twice as much time as necessary to transcribe their reports. This would be a win-win for everyone. The MTs would be able to produce more work in less time and make more money.

Anonymous said...

Very well said! You go girl (and guys)! Its about time someone took the time to rant about this. I believe we should boycott these companies that take away from Americans for pennies! This is insane we have worked hard to get most of these companies where they are today just to be insulted with outsourcing! I will surely follow this and add comments and suggestions! But, we need to stand up and be heard! I am ready to get loud.

Anonymous said...

Proofreading these reports is imperative. I urge everyone to ask their physician if they've proofread a report lately - they're too busy. We now have electronic signatures. God help us all.

Rant on - I love it, and so should you! I don't dislike the foreign transcriptionists, it's their "owners" who need policing. Kind of works like prostitution, I think. (And they're not all from that country, they are just the "deal makers" with some Americans for profit). Speak up, please,we just did.

Anonymous said...

How true, how true. I have been a transcriptionist for 4 years. I started with over 8 docs and I am now down to 2 because of the outsourcing to India. The Owner of my company of course is of Indian decent. These National companies are insane thinking we will work for a low wage. I make 12 cents a line and they want to pay 6 cents. Are they nuts? I have decided to go back to school to get my CPC coding as I did billing for 12 years prior and wanted to find a job that I could do at home. Boy, what a mistake. I was approached by a National company and I wrote this at MT stars: Can anyone out there explain to me why when taking a test for a national company they would tell you, Note: The audio is bad and that is part of the test. Why in the world would a company want to give you a bad audio tape to test on? Is this a Joke? I feel this is very humiliating to a transcriptionist. Just give a decent test. How is anyone supposed to pass it if the audio is bad? I do not care who you are and how many years experience, if the audio is bad, then no one is going to pass. This is totally ridiculous. I am glad I am starting to look into coding for a new profession because these National companies are making a mockery of this field, which was once respected. The goverment is at fault. My husband is a Steel worker and work is going to other countries. What ever happened to helping our own people here. Take a look next time you put on a piece of clothing, I bet you cannot say it is from the US. We need to stop this outsourching and take care of our own. I am ready to rant.

Anonymous said...

Condoms 'too big' for Indian men
By Damian Grammaticus
BBC News, Delhi

There is a "lack of awareness" over condom sizes
A survey of more than 1,000 men in India has concluded that condoms made according to international sizes are too large for a majority of Indian men.

The study found that more than half of the men measured had penises that were shorter than international standards for condoms.

It has led to a call for condoms of mixed sizes to be made more widely available in India.

The two-year study was carried out by the Indian Council of Medical Research.

Over 1,200 volunteers from the length and breadth of the country had their penises measured precisely, down to the last millimetre.

The scientists even checked their sample was representative of India as a whole in terms of class, religion and urban and rural dwellers.

Sunil Mehra
The conclusion of all this scientific endeavour is that about 60% of Indian men have penises which are between three and five centimetres shorter than international standards used in condom manufacture.

Doctor Chander Puri, a specialist in reproductive health at the Indian Council of Medical Research, told the BBC there was an obvious need in India for custom-made condoms, as most of those currently on sale are too large.

The issue is serious because about one in every five times a condom is used in India it either falls off or tears, an extremely high failure rate.

And the country already has the highest number of HIV infections of any nation.

'Not a problem'

Mr Puri said that since Indians would be embarrassed about going to a chemist to ask for smaller condoms there should be vending machines dispensing different sizes all around the country.

"Smaller condoms are on sale in India. But there is a lack of awareness that different sizes are available. There is anxiety talking about the issue. And normally one feels shy to go to a chemist's shop and ask for a smaller size condom."

But Indian men need not be concerned about measuring up internationally according to Sunil Mehra, the former editor of the Indian version of the men's magazine Maxim.

"It's not size, it's what you do with it that matters," he said.

"From our population, the evidence is Indians are doing pretty well.

"With apologies to the poet Alexander Pope, you could say, for inches and centimetres, let fools contend."

Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/south_asia/6161691.stm

Published: 2006/12/08 13:08:43 GMT

D Phanchalad said...

UTAH : Utah Web Design http://www.adaptivitypro.com/utah-web-design/